all right Mr ganas I just want one last question I’m going to show you a draft email that you provided to the committee Mr uh Mr chairman I yield objection on time uh good job chair now recognize Mr Crockett for one minute or five minutes one minute all right uh first of all uh me Mr bubinski do you know who elections LLC is yeah back well it’s not a who okay well do you know what it is yes it’s a LLC okay and is it the LLC that your attorney works for uh I believe so yes you believe so okay um so at this point in

time I’d ask unanimous consent to enter into the record a document indicating that the law firm representing Tony balinski was paid $10,000 as recently as January of this year by the save America pack which you may recognize is Donald Trump’s pack without objection thank you now so far in this hearing it has felt like the worst episode of The Apprentice I’m sure you’re familiar with that show it seems like my colleagues and maybe you and some others are trying to become the next Vice President of the United

States of America you’re auditioning or something like that because Mr balinsky I know that you take exception to the fact that your credibility has been called into question over and over but when someone comes to testify under oath whether it’s before this committee behind closed doors or in person then we have to evaluate someone’s credibility and sir I definitely have always had issues with your credibility as I know that you are very well aware of so let me remind you of what happened behind closed doors I have

ask you a question okay you are when I I haven’t so when I ask you a question that’s when you answer otherwise I’m talking so excuse me with my time cuz it’s my time I want to be clear that when we were behind closed doors you called a number of people Liars you called The Wall Street Journal Liars you called Cassidy Hutchinson a liar you called the FBI a liar you called Rob Walker a liar you called James Giller a liar you called Hunter Biden a liar you called Jim Biden a liar and just today you added to your

list you called my colleague Congressman Mr Goldman a liar as well it seems like according to you the only person that’s telling the truth is you and everyone else is lying but I want to move on to something else is that a question or it’s not a question okay you’ll know when I ask you a question I promise thank you so the other thing that I want to talk about is um the fact that my colleague from the other side of the aisle talked about the company that we keep and she wanted to go through a list of people that she felt like were bad

company because right now the majority has been relying upon the testimony of someone who’s currently sitting in federal prison and we know that your company is the company of somebody who’s been found liable of fraud uh as well as defamation as well as sexual uh assault and for whatever reason can’t pay his bills uh at this point in time but I’m going to ask Mr parnis so this is a question to him are you aware if Trump had any Associates that have been found guilty of anything yes lots of them lots of them me included you included okay so when

you were called here to testify you weren’t called here to testify for any other reason than to tell the truth is that correct yes congresswoman now we started this whole sham off because of the 1023 and that was debunked by you was it not yes Congressman way before we started this impeachment inquiry and you mentioned a number of times this guy by the name of Rudy Giuliani yes now you know everybody is so stressed about the fact that Hunter ain’t here today but you know Hunter came and testified behind closed doors for over 6 hours and

every single one of them they weren’t limited to 5 minutes they could to ask whatever they wanted to and there’s a full transcript of his testimony so I don’t know what else they wanted to do besides the fact that they wanted to put on the show but let me tell you something this whole thing is based upon something that Giuliani came up with yes and and we tried to subpoena him if I’m that’s what I remember if anybody else remember we try we asked we said hey we should subpoena Giuliani but you know kind of like when we were trying to get

his cell phone they shut it down right like they don’t want the facts but you would agree with me that considering the fact that you were working under Rudy Giuliani at the time that you went over to Ukraine that he has maybe some valuable information that he could offer this committee as to whether or not there’s anything that we should be investigating in the first place absolutely congresswoman I wish that this committee would subpoena Rudy Giuliani put him under oath alongside me to get to the bottom of the truth of

what actually happened in Ukraine and to the manipulation that Trump and Giuliani and the team went to do I I agree with you but somehow it doesn’t look like we’re going to get there and I thank you for your time all yield time’s expired chair now recognizes Mr Bigs from Arizona thank you Mr chairman Mr galanis on May 9th 2014 you received an email from Devon Archer confirming or